The first American Falls Dam served for half a century, but by the 1960s it was failing from the inside. A core-drilling program in the early 1960s revealed that the concrete in portions of the original dam was in a relatively advanced stage of deterioration, caused by a chemical reaction between the alkalis in the cement and the aggregate. The reaction caused a significant loss of strength and durability, and officials imposed a fill restriction that reduced the reservoir's storage to about sixty-six percent of its maximum design capacity. A dam that farmers depended on for drought insurance could no longer be trusted to hold a full reservoir.
Congress answered on December 28, 1973. An act of that date authorized the American Falls Reservoir District, acting as the constructing agency representing the storage spaceholders, to finance and contract for the replacement of American Falls Dam. The arrangement was unusual. The water users themselves, the irrigation districts and farmers who held space in the reservoir, would finance and build the new federal dam, and when the work was done, Reclamation would repay the district, acquire title, and assume responsibility for operations and maintenance.
The new dam rose downstream of the old one, and construction ran from 1976 to 1978. In 1976, Idaho Power Company built the current hydroelectric powerplant at the dam, with three generators. Reclamation gives the plant's authorized output as 92.4 megawatts, and Idaho Power's own figures give a nameplate total of 92,340 kilowatts for the three units. The powerhouse and the dam were built together as one project, so that the replacement would restore both the storage the farmers had lost and the power generation the falls had supported since 1902.
The summer of 1976 brought a frightening test before the new dam was finished. In June of that year, the upstream Teton Dam failed during its first filling, sending snowmelt racing down the Teton River into the Snake and demolishing towns along its path. Operators at American Falls released water as quickly as possible to make room for the surge, fearing what the flood could do to the deteriorating old dam and to the dams below it. The reservoir filled, but its level did not even rise to the spillway crest, and American Falls held.
Not everyone welcomed the replacement. When the second dam was planned, members of the Shoshone and Bannock communities opposed expansion, because it would further flood the lands of the Fort Hall Bottoms, the river bottom country along the Snake that Native people have inhabited and used for at least 10,000 years. Many scientists were opposed as well, because of the loss of natural habitat and of access to the fossil records of the Bottoms. Their objections are part of the project's record, even though the dam went forward.
Construction was completed in 1978, and the original structure was demolished. Reclamation repaid the district, acquired title, and assumed responsibility for operations and maintenance after completion. One earlier Reclamation plan dates the replacement to 1977, but the Bureau's later and more detailed environmental assessment gives 1978, the year used here. Today the division of labor is settled: the Bureau of Reclamation operates the dam and reservoir as part of the Minidoka Project and controls reservoir releases and headwater levels, while Idaho Power owns and operates the powerplant. State Highway 39 crosses the top of the concrete gravity dam for more than half a mile, and every driver who crosses drives over the machinery of the replacement.